I encourage you to personally tour the school and meet the educators and students, form your own opinion and leave a comment here.
Best of luck with your search for the perfect school!
To understand the real arguments behind the co-ed versus single-sex debate, we’ve analysed hundreds of comments from passionate discussions in Melbourne parent groups, where families share their genuine experiences, fears, and the reasoning behind their choices.
They provide some insights into the thought processes of parents when they choose single sex schools or co-ed schools for their son or daughter. They’re raw, honest conversations from parents grappling with a decision that will shape their children’s social development, academic future, and worldview.
From mothers describing their daughters finally finding their voice in all-girls classrooms to fathers worried their sons are missing out on learning to interact with women, from parents celebrating the real-world preparation of co-ed schools to those convinced single-sex education saved their child’s confidence. These discussions reveal deep convictions, surprising trade-offs, and sometimes uncomfortable admissions about what really happens in different school environments.
Understanding what parents are choosing between
When parents talk about co-educational schools, they’re discussing environments where boys and girls learn together in the same classrooms. These schools aim to mirror the real world, encouraging students to work and socialise across gender lines from an early age.
Single-sex schools take the opposite approach, educating boys and girls separately. Parents who choose these schools often mention that teaching can be tailored specifically to how their sons or daughters learn best, without the social dynamics that come with mixed classrooms.
Why parents choose co-ed schools
“The real world isn’t separated”
Parents who advocate for co-ed schools consistently bring up the same key point in discussion groups. The real world isn’t separated by gender, they argue, so why should schools be? These parents want their children comfortable working with everyone from day one.
Breaking down gender stereotypes
A common sentiment among co-ed supporters is that mixed classrooms naturally challenge kids to step outside gender stereotypes. Parents share stories of their daughters confidently tackling robotics clubs and their sons joining drama productions without a second thought. They believe this only happens when both genders learn side by side and see each other succeeding in all areas.
Building social intelligence
The social development aspect dominates many parent conversations. Families value how their children learn to read different communication styles, handle diverse friendships, and develop what many call “real emotional intelligence.” Parents often mention their kids are less awkward around the opposite gender compared to children from single-sex schools.
Normalising gender interactions
Parents also appreciate the everyday normalisation of gender interactions. Rather than the opposite gender being mysterious or different, co-ed students see them as classmates, project partners, and friends. Many parents believe this leads to healthier relationships later in life.
The concerns parents share
However, concerns do surface in these discussions. Some parents worry about classroom dynamics where louder students (often boys, according to parent observations) dominate discussions. Others have noticed their daughters becoming quieter in certain subjects when boys are present. These concerns lead some families to reconsider their co-ed choice, especially during the middle school years.
Why parents choose single-sex schools
Academic focus without the drama
The discussions around single-sex schools reveal some passionate advocates, particularly among parents who’ve made the switch from co-ed. The number one reason? Academic focus without the social drama. Parents repeatedly describe the transformation they’ve witnessed when their children moved to single-sex environments. Teenage boys aren’t showing off for girls. Girls aren’t worried about looking too smart or too keen in front of boys. The whole exhausting performance just disappears, parents say, and kids can finally just learn.
Girls finding their voice
Mothers of daughters share particularly strong views. Many describe years of frustration watching their girls shrink in co-ed classrooms – not raising hands, not taking risks, not putting themselves forward. These same girls, they report, become debate captains and maths champions in all-girls settings. The difference is dramatic and immediate, according to parent accounts.
Boys free to be themselves
Parents of boys tell similar stories from a different angle. Their sons feel free to embrace interests without worrying about being judged. Boys who love reading aren’t hiding their books. Those interested in music or art aren’t dropping these subjects to seem more masculine. Parents say the pressure to fit narrow stereotypes simply vanishes.
A calmer classroom environment
The classroom atmosphere itself gets significant attention in parent forums. Words like “calm,” “focused,” and “supportive” appear constantly. Parents describe visiting their children’s single-sex classrooms and being struck by the productive buzz, the willingness to ask questions, and the absence of showing off or put-downs.
Protection during vulnerable years
Safety concerns, particularly around teenage behaviour, also influence parent decisions. Many parents feel single-sex schools provide a more controlled environment during the vulnerable adolescent years, with fewer distractions from relationship dramas and social pressures that can derail academic progress.
The concerns about single-sex education
Not all parents are convinced. A significant number worry that separating genders doesn’t prepare students for university or the workplace. Several parents shared stories of their children struggling socially when transitioning from single-sex high schools to mixed university environments.
Some parents feel single-sex schools can actually reinforce gender stereotypes rather than break them down. They worry about creating an artificial divide between boys and girls that doesn’t exist in the real world.
The question of inclusivity also comes up frequently in parent forums, with concerns about how single-sex schools accommodate students who don’t fit traditional gender categories.
What parents say works best
Many Melbourne parents have found success with a blended approach – co-ed primary school followed by single-sex secondary education. They feel this gives children the social benefits of mixed learning when they’re young, then allows for focused academic development during the teenage years.
Several families praised schools that operate a “parallel learning” model – where boys and girls learn in separate classes but come together for certain activities and events. Schools like Haileybury and Tintern Grammar use this approach, and parents say it offers the best of both worlds.
The gender difference according to parents
A striking pattern emerges from parent discussions: many believe co-education benefits boys more than girls. Parents observe that boys often perform better academically when girls are present to model focus and maturity. Meanwhile, numerous parents report their daughters thriving academically and socially in all-girls environments where they don’t have to compete for attention.
One parent summed it up well: academically capable boys seem to do better in co-ed schools where they benefit from the strong academic culture, but girls often excel in single-sex schools where they have more space to develop confidence.
However, parents of quieter or less confident boys often prefer single-sex settings where teachers can better address male-specific learning patterns without comparison to girls.
Real experiences from Melbourne families
The experiences vary dramatically across Melbourne families:
- Parents with daughters in all-girls schools consistently praise the calmer classroom environment and note significant confidence improvements. These parents often mention their daughters taking on leadership roles they wouldn’t have pursued in co-ed settings.
- Families who’ve moved boys from single-sex to co-ed schools frequently comment on improvements in empathy and social skills. They notice their sons becoming more comfortable expressing emotions and building friendships across genders.
- Some parents express frustration with the social limitations of single-sex schools. They worry their children miss out on learning to interact naturally with the opposite gender, which can create awkwardness later in life.
- Others recommend the progressive approach: co-ed for primary school to build social foundations, then single-sex for secondary school to maximise academic focus during crucial years.
What parents are saying now
Current parent discussions show no clear winner in the debate. Instead, the consensus is that success depends more on finding the right fit for each individual child. Parents emphasise looking at school culture, teaching quality, and their child’s personality rather than focusing solely on whether the school is co-ed or single-sex.
What comes through clearly is that when a school environment supports a student’s confidence and wellbeing – whether that’s co-ed or single-sex – the child is more likely to thrive academically and socially.
The bottom line from parents
The passionate discussions in parent forums reflect deeper questions about what we value in education. For some families, co-ed settings build resilience and real-world readiness. For others, single-sex environments provide the focused, supportive space their children need to excel.
The most balanced view from parents seems to be about flexibility and individual fit. Many emphasise that there’s no one-size-fits-all answer – what works brilliantly for one child might be completely wrong for their sibling.
Ultimately, parents agree that the choice between co-educational and single-sex schools should be based on knowing your child. Consider their temperament, learning style, social confidence, and individual needs rather than following trends or traditions. The right environment is the one where your child feels supported, challenged, and able to be themselves.
About Author
